You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: kerys Signed [Report This]
Date: 20 Oct 2013 23:39 Title: 10x15 - "Inside Out"

I almost quit several episodes ago when Bashir was so grossly mischaracterized. I'm SO glad I stayed on. You had me cackling with glee over your revelation that it was all an act. Bravo!

Author's Response:

Thanks! Glad you liked it. 

Reviewer: Ln X Signed [Report This]
Date: 17 Jun 2012 17:45 Title: 10x22 - "Ascension" (3 of 3)

That was one slick story, with some tense action sequences and clever ways of tying everything together.

Author's Response:

Thanks! Glad you liked.

Reviewer: Ln X Signed [Report This]
Date: 31 May 2012 03:07 Title: 10x03 - "Steppin' Out"

Maybe I've gone stark raving mad but how can Vic leave the holosuite (without a mobile emitter) and still exist? I'm missing something here...

Anyway I'll be a few weeks until I read this story, I got some other series to read Gibraltar and Tesserect before I come back to this one.

Author's Response:

That's kind of the whole point of the story. Keep reading. All will become clear.

Reviewer: Ln X Signed [Report This]
Date: 28 May 2012 18:34 Title: 10x02 - "Brave New World"

Things are getting rather weird: the Ohalavar movement, alternate universes, Founders searching for their OWN god... I'm starting to wonder what is real and what isn't it because it all seems very strange, a bit too strange.

I did enjoy this story though, however I get the feeling that the following stories require a rather good knowledge of the DS9R books...

Author's Response:

The beginning of the season was specifically designed to tie off loose ends and put everything back into place after the big mess it was in at the end of last season. As it goes on, the season gets slightly less dependent on what went before... and then more dependent again. But hopefully I'll have explained what you need to know when you need to know it.

As for the Founders' God, the Progenitor was also an invention of season 9. The idea was that the Founders are infertile, they have no way of reproducing. But since they can still be killed, they are slowly dying out. That's the real reason they created the Dominion - to protect themselves - and the reason they sent out the Hundred - to lure the Progenitor back in, the entity some of them believe created their people, to save them. It worked, the Progenitor returned... and then the Ascendants killed it. The resulting existential despair led the Founders to abandon the Link and disperse out into the galaxy, leading to the state the Dominion is in now.

Reviewer: Ln X Signed [Report This]
Date: 28 May 2012 18:25 Title: 10x02 - "Brave New World"

Some really odd mysteries going on here. As for the Prophets and their timeline, I kind of imagine they see every point in time, or any point they wish to see. But add all these alternate universes... There are potentially an infinite number, so how the Prophets could make sense of it all I don't know.

Author's Response:

The alternate universes bit came into it in "season 9", which revealed that all Siskos, in all alternate universes, were supposed to all be their respective Emissaries. And the fact the Mirror Universe version of Sisko was already dead had left kind of a vacuum that demanded to be filled - something Iliana Ghemor intended to do. That led to the convoluted plan Sisko and Vaughn are arguing over. That the Prophets set this plan in motion based on Sisko's own advice about alternate universes is my own invention.

Reviewer: Ln X Signed [Report This]
Date: 28 May 2012 18:12 Title: 10x02 - "Brave New World"

I like all this Bajoran politics amongst the Vedek Assembly. Seems the two canditates are politically motivated (i.e. fundamentalist) then spiritually motivated.

Author's Response:

I've been subtly casting Solis as kind of my Obama figure - how the opposition will tie themselves into knots trying to find something to accuse him of, when what's underneath it all is just a bigoted dislike of who and what he is. It's not a big part of things, just background info.

Reviewer: Ln X Signed [Report This]
Date: 28 May 2012 15:14 Title: 10x02 - "Brave New World"

I rather enjoyed that chapter, and Opaka is there to? Clearly a lot of crazy stuff happened in the DS9R books! Rebecca was really cute, and I thought Sisko's dialogue was spot on. It sounded like Sisko...

Poor Odo; now he will probably never return to Kira because he has the impossible task of managing the Dominion without the Great Link helping him. Or maybe the Jem'Hadar will go all crazy, fight amongst themselves (seems like they already are) and there won't be a Dominion left. In that case Odo will have no choice but to return to DS9 as it is the only home he has left...

I hope Odo and Kira meet up in your series... Would be really sweet...

Author's Response:

After a few years on the Ennis planet, Opaka was rescued by... ironically... an Ascendant. She met Jake on his adventures on the Even Odds (the pirate ship from ep 1) and together they discovered another species called the Eavoq, on the Gamma end of the wormhole, who had been influenced by the Prophets. Then she came back to Bajor and has been politely declining people's requests that she take back over as Kai again.

Reviewer: Ln X Signed [Report This]
Date: 28 May 2012 14:55 Title: 10x02 - "Brave New World"

Aw! Kira sounds a bit like Janeway with that family reference! I really getting into the script format; it's short, it flows and can be surprisingly descriptive at times.

I'm still reeling a bit mentally though because of the name of Sisko and Kasidy's child; Rebecca. I've never read any DS9R books so I had no idea whether Kasidy's unborn baby was a boy or girl. Being forced to improvise for one of my stories (which is part of a separate trek-verse after the Dominion war) I came up with the same name by sheer chance!

Egads! But I'm looking forward to this birthday party! Hopefully all four Siskos will be there...

Author's Response:

I haven't brought Joseph in if that's what you mean. He appeared in earlier DS9-R novels, but I didn't really have a role for him in my stories. As for Dax, I got it muddled before - she's only a Lieutenant at this point, but gets promoted to Lieutenant Commander in a later episode.

Reviewer: Ln X Signed [Report This]
Date: 28 May 2012 02:26 Title: 10x01 - "Emancipation"

I have to say that is one interesting story, and one clever way of starting a season. I was pleasantly surprised by this story, and I am looking forward to reading the next one.

Author's Response:

Good - glad you enjoyed it!

Reviewer: Ln X Signed [Report This]
Date: 28 May 2012 02:17 Title: 10x01 - "Emancipation"

Erm, just what is Dax's rank? Lieutenant Commander or something? Another interesting thing is how you portray Batanides. In Star Trek Rogue (that TNG Section 31 book) she is all against Section 31, and yet in your story she acts in a very Section 31-like way (unless you have to be rather devious and secretive in SI). I have the feeling Batanides wants Dax to join her 'group' whatever that is. Thought-provoking stuff...

Author's Response:

Yes, I would say Dax is Lt Cmdr. As for Batanides, she's very much anti-Section 31. She and Vaughn are part of an even-more-secret-than-them anti-S31 group, and that's who both of them are looking for recruits for. In Rogue she's part of Starfleet Intelligence, but I shifted her to Human Resources for a very specific reason.

Reviewer: Ln X Signed [Report This]
Date: 28 May 2012 02:05 Title: 10x01 - "Emancipation"

The 'interrogations' continue, I'll say this: you did a good job recapping events for DS9R readers, but sadly for the non-readers (or for me at least) these events don't mean much. Never mind, this is still an engaging story even if you don't half the backstory...

Reviewer: Ln X Signed [Report This]
Date: 28 May 2012 01:59 Title: 10x01 - "Emancipation"

A nice little chapter introducing the status of DS9 and how the crew fit into it. No First Minister Shakaar? And what's up with Dax?

Author's Response:

I suppose you wouldn't know this if you hadn't read the previous novels, but Shakaar is dead at this point. He was killed during "season 8," and his former second minister, a woman named Asarem Wadeen, is now First Minister. She assigned her ex-husband, a familiar face named Krim Aldos (from The Circle trilogy) as Bajoran Councillor on the Federation Council once Bajor joined up at the end of season 8.

Reviewer: Ln X Signed [Report This]
Date: 26 May 2012 19:49 Title: 10x01 - "Emancipation"

Still reading and right now I'm not sure what to make of this story, but I will continue reading...

Reviewer: Ln X Signed [Report This]
Date: 26 May 2012 19:37 Title: 10x01 - "Emancipation"

I like the script format. It conveys scenes, rooms and events quickly, precisely and smoothly. It also seems that your chapters (or episode length) is about the same size of an actual Star Trek script, so it's a quick read which I also like.

I'm completely unfamiliar with the characters (I have never read the DS9R books!) but hopefully your story will help me be introduced with these characters without feeling I'm missing out on too much previous information/stories.

Reviewer: Ln X Signed [Report This]
Date: 22 May 2012 18:22 Title: 10x10 - "In Two Minds"

"No no."

Phew! I thought beforehand that Kira was actually Iliana and this made me stop reading the story as I couldn't stomach the thought of Kira really being a Cardassian. Will continue reading.

Reviewer: Ln X Signed [Report This]
Date: 19 Apr 2012 11:50 Title: 10x10 - "In Two Minds"

"FLASHBACK – 9x21 “FEARFUL SYMMETRY”

Dukat advances on the memory-wiped Iliana, in her cell on Letau, he with a sadistic grin, her screaming in terror...
"

Is this really Kira's memory? If so is she actually Iliana and the real Kira Nerys is dead?

Author's Response:

No no. I see where you're getting that from, maybe I wasn't clear enough. My bad.

But there's a moment at the end of The Soul Key, in the scene where all three "Kiras" are together in the wormhole, where our Kira (the real Kira) gets a blast of all of Iliana's memories courtesy of the Prophets. It was said that it finally helped her to understand what Iliana had gone through, because up to then she hadn't known the full story. That's where she gets that memory from now. So it definitely is the real Kira. I'm not doing any body-swap stuff.

Reviewer: Ln X Signed [Report This]
Date: 19 Apr 2012 11:38 Title: 10x09 - "Blank Slate"

Engaging story, I'm a little weary of DS9R stories because they seem overdramatic, but this one was good.

Author's Response:

Yeah, there haven't been a lot of light-hearted stories since Avatar. That's why I made an effort to have a few more in my season - 3, 8 and 17 have their light moments, and 13 is flat out comedy.

Reviewer: RobertScorpio Signed [Report This]
Date: 06 Apr 2012 14:02 Title: 10x16 - "I Will Survive"

lvsxy808...this was a blast to read. I really like the script format. Takes me back to when I had submitted a script (actually three) to Star Trek back in the day when they did that sort of thing. When done in script form, as this is, it really gives the reader a fresh way to take something in and I like it. One to part two...

Rob

Author's Response:

Glad you like it. Thanks for keeping on reading!

Reviewer: Kirok-Of-LStok Signed [Report This]
Date: 31 Mar 2012 14:29 Title: 10x01 - "Emancipation"

Script-based fan fiction is very common in web-series, which is frankly what I would call this impressive project you have here. I'm trying to get 100 posts up on TrekBBS so I can post graphics so I'll be dropping comments on there. Persevere with AdAstra though -they are more likely to comment!

K

Reviewer: Gul Rejal Signed [Report This]
Date: 31 Oct 2011 07:48 Title: 10x07 - "Instinct"

So, it got to Kira how much she misses Yoshi, now that he is on the station. I'm not surprised at all. He might not be genetically hers, but there's no doubt that her connection to him is strong. And Yoshi playing the the shuttle all the time is just cute!

Nog. I think he showed a lot of patience; I would have lost mine much earlier. O'Brien has good intentions, but criticising everything was not a good approach to offer his help. I'm glad that they clarified it in the end and no hard feelings hang over them.

As to Cardassia. The reason for their isolation is completely different, but I find it an interesting coincidence that we both decided to lock their borders and made them reject all help. I always felt they were proud people and endlessly taking stuff from others made them uncomfortable. The virus might be one of reasons why they want to be left alone and lick their wounds undisturbed.
I am concerned, though, that a former Obsidian Order agent is having such an important function. She should be held responsible for her past, just like Garak, not made a part of ruling people. That is the first step to turning back to an oppressive regime the Cardassians had before the Dominion War.

I wonder if Taran'atar is losing his mind. Dreams are one thing, hallucinations and talking to non-existing people another.

 

Reviewer: Gul Rejal Signed Liked [Report This]
Date: 10 Oct 2011 02:27 Title: 10x04 - "Easy Come, Easy Go"

I'm happy to see Shar returning to DS9! He's one of my favourite characters from the novels. That said, I'm not at all impressed by his attempt to cheat on his big family and I fully agree with Prynn--it's not okay. She made the right thing refusing to have any relationship with a married man (and married with three other people at that!).

As I said on TrekBBS forum, I'm not sure I'd have a conversation with my own father about my sexual life, but maybe such things changed in the past centuries (or future centuries from my point of view). Or Prynn is just open about subjects like that.

Good to see that Odo didn't cut Taran'atar to pieces after getting news of the Jem'hadar attack on her. Of course, Odo is above petty bloody revenge.

This was a good, interesting episode :)



Author's Response: Well, I still say that Prynn wasn't talking about her sex life. She just mentioned that she briefly considered dating women. That's not the same thing as explicit sexual descriptions, not by a long shot.

Reviewer: Nerys Ghemor Signed [Report This]
Date: 08 Oct 2011 02:41 Title: 10x03 - "Steppin' Out"

I've got to say it.  I normally hate screenplay-type episodes.  I cannot stand trying to tough through that kind of thing in written format.

But this was an exception to what is normally a hard-and-fast rule.

I will admit that the first reason I decided to actually try it was because one of my friends, Gul Re'jal read it.  She has very good taste, and I certainly was rewarded with a good story, and I really could see how it would appear on screen.

I think you did an excellent job tackling the issues that Vic's obvious sentience should've raised.  The attitudes we saw Matthias espousing really reminded me of Sisko's offensive rant in "Badda Bing, Badda Bang," where he thought it was OK, because he didn't like Vic's appearance, to kill a unique and alien life form that was not a 1960's human, just inspired by one.  Might as well off the Sigma Iotians if you don't like Chicago; that's how logical that was.

It got even more disturbing watching them talk about turning him off because of his privacy violation; it really, really sounded like the way one would talk about euthanizing a dog that bit someone.  Leaving the animal debate aside, to see Vic talked about as a mechanical animal was galling!

I liked seeing how Vic has internalized his 24th-century surroundings; we definitely saw evidence of that on the show, but it really seems that psychologically--given that I do think Vic is a fully sentient being--it would be painful to be confined.  Just as we saw the Doctor on VOY begin to expand beyond his programming, it seems Vic is clearly doing so.  For him to remain confined must be dangerous for him.

When he doesn't have the emitter (which was very nice of the Doctor to lend him), shouldn't Vic be given access to something special to keep his mind growing and keep him from being bored and lonely?  I hope your characters will begin to address that issue.

Good job!

Reviewer: Gul Rejal Signed [Report This]
Date: 04 Oct 2011 01:00 Title: 10x03 - "Steppin' Out"

A nice Vic-centered episode. It seems that after the taste of life Nog had given him, Vic wants more, much more, and created a whole station for himself, where he can interact with his friends.

I first I had thought that he somehow got a portable holo-emitter, but the truth occurred to be more complicated than that.

In the end Vic learnt, not for the first time, that he has real friends and his world doesn't have to be only holographic.

Reviewer: Gul Rejal Signed [Report This]
Date: 25 Sep 2011 04:18 Title: 10x01 - "Emancipation"

Glad to see you here, lvsxy808.

Some unanswered questions we have after this episode; a bit like setting new problems, conflicts and subjects for the upcoming season. An episode-lenght teaser.

When I first started reading, the format bothered me a bit, but I quickly passed by that and got used to it, so after some time it stopped being an issue. Now the characters and events draw my attention, as it should be.

BTW, to reply to reviews, you might want to use "Respond" feature (you can find it under each posted review) instead of writing a response as another review. That way your reviewer would also be notified my email of your response.



Author's Response: Thanks Gul Rejal! Still figuring stuff out here, there'll be some teething pains. New episode uploaded each week until the schedule syncs with TrekBBS.

Reviewer: lvsxy808 Signed [Report This]
Date: 22 Sep 2011 14:17 Title: 10x01 - "Emancipation"

@ Ln X

By "usual format," do you mean prose rather than screenplay? If so, then no, sorry, I don't - I've only written them as screenplays, using Word and then saved into PDF. But thanks for reading!

No results found.
You must login (register) to review.